Dark Mode Light Mode
Witkoff and Kushner in Moscow: Europe Offside
Shenzhen: The Stage Where Beijing Receives the Great Powers

Shenzhen: The Stage Where Beijing Receives the Great Powers

For the first time, the leaders of the world’s three principal nuclear powers are expected to meet together. The setting has not been left to chance: it will be China, in Shenzhen, on the sidelines of the APEC summit opening tomorrow on 18 November. Donald Trump has announced that he expects to see Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin there, and Beijing has confirmed that preparations are under way.

Forum or Ceremony?

APEC, which brings together twenty-one economies around the Pacific Rim, has long been a venue for relatively free exchanges between leaders. The Chinese edition breaks with that tradition. Gone is the informal retreat where heads of state could talk without protocol: instead, each leader is invited to the Kylin Villa, a state residence on the outskirts of Shenzhen, for a one-on-one meeting with Xi Jinping. Part of the proceedings, including the ministerial meeting, will take place online. Several diplomats see this as more than a matter of logistics: by limiting the opportunities for participants to talk among themselves, Beijing may be seeking to ensure that it sits at the centre of every conversation.

Nor is the choice of Shenzhen a neutral one. The city is the country’s technological showcase, and the Chinese leadership intends to use it to present itself as the guarantor of the multilateral order, at a time when Washington is shaking the very system it built after the Second World War. In late October, Qi Yu, Party Secretary of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, set out the line in no uncertain terms. He called for promoting abroad “the glorious image and noble stature” of Xi Jinping, “a world-class leader of a great party and a great country,” and for generating worldwide momentum to “look East” and “learn from the Communist Party of China.” The Shenzhen summit will be the staging of that programme.

An Agenda That Matters Less Than the Image

Washington wants to talk about denuclearisation. The subject is a sensitive one for Beijing, which has so far declined any three-way negotiation: its arsenal, though growing fast, still lags far behind those of the United States and Russia, and China has no intention of freezing it at that level. Donald Trump also wishes to raise the war in Iran.

Ukraine, by contrast, is not expected to dominate the three-way meeting, even though Vladimir Putin would like to put it on the table and is due to discuss it one-on-one with his American counterpart, following on from Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner’s visit to the Kremlin.

Ultimately, it would be surprising if the meeting produced a concrete agreement. Its significance lies elsewhere: in the photograph itself, and in what it will tell the rest of the world about the hierarchy of powers.

Two Designated Winners

The first is Vladimir Putin. Little more than a year ago, he was received in Anchorage, on American soil. Now he sits at the table with the American and Chinese presidents as an equal. For the Kremlin, this is proof that Russia has not been isolated by the war in Ukraine: it has held its own against NATO and remains one of the three poles of the international system.

The second is the host. Xi Jinping, whose support was decisive in enabling Russia to pursue the war, is presenting himself as the leader of a responsible power and as the intermediary between Moscow and Washington. To receive the other two major nuclear powers on one’s own soil is to show that the world’s great affairs are now settled in the East – exactly what Qi Yu had called for.

Receive neutral, factual information

By clicking on the ‘Subscribe’ button, you confirm that you have read and accept our privacy policy and terms of use.