Last week, on 12 November, Vladimir Putin received Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, Donald Trump’s envoys, at the Kremlin. The meeting followed two days of trilateral talks between the Americans, Russians and Ukrainians in Abu Dhabi. The visit confirmed that peace in Ukraine is being negotiated first and foremost between Washington and Moscow – without the Europeans.
A Dialogue Between Those Who Matter
As we had anticipated, the Abu Dhabi talks produced no breakthrough. The Moscow visit is nonetheless encouraging. Its significance lies first in who is talking: the United States and the Russian Federation, the two superpowers involved in this war. American intelligence is vital to Ukraine. Without it, the already slim chances of a Ukrainian victory would vanish altogether. Because the United States has a direct bearing on the outcome of the war, direct exchanges between Americans and Russians are indispensable. They will continue at the highest level: Vladimir Putin and Donald Trump are due to resume their discussions at the end of November, on the sidelines of the APEC summit in China.
One might have expected the 12 November meeting to be a formality, somewhat hollow. It was nothing of the sort, as Vladimir Putin himself took up the most contentious issues. The Russian president declared that, for Russia, there is only one dividing line with Ukraine: the state border. In other words, the four Ukrainian oblasts annexed to Russia by referendum in September 2022 will remain Russian. Vladimir Putin also proposed a humanitarian mission to Kostiantynivka to evacuate the civilians still there, in the presence of foreign journalists. A way of having it publicly acknowledged that the town is held by Russian forces?
The Russian Logic: A Lasting Peace, Not a Respite
Russia believes it is winning on the battlefield. That is why it does not want a mere ceasefire. A truce would give the enemy time to regroup, rebuild its forces and rearm. Vladimir Putin told the American envoys plainly that he wanted a lasting peace, one that addresses the root causes of the conflict, not a pause before the next war.
This is the key to understanding the negotiations: Moscow is not seeking a territorial settlement in Ukraine alone. Since 2008, it has been calling for a renegotiation of Europe’s security architecture. The meeting between Vladimir Putin, Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner at the Kremlin, following the Abu Dhabi talks, confirms that this question now lies at the heart of the dialogue between Washington and Moscow.
What we know of Russia’s demands, thanks to the German newspaper Bild, gives a sense of the scale of this ambition. They go far beyond the status of Ukraine. Moscow reportedly seeks Ukraine’s permanent neutrality and its renunciation of NATO membership, while leaving the door open to its joining the European Union. Russia’s demands are said to include Finland’s withdrawal from the Atlantic Alliance, which it joined only in 2023. The Baltic states would also be affected, barred from hosting NATO military bases. Moldova would be subject to special arrangements concerning Transnistria and Gagauzia, while the Ukrainian ports of Odesa and Mykolaiv would be demilitarised.
Although Moscow has not officially confirmed all of these proposals, they all follow the same logic: Russia intends to secure guarantees that will prevent any future expansion of Western military influence in its neighbourhood.
This ambition is hardly surprising. As early as December 2021, before the invasion of Ukraine began, Moscow presented Washington and NATO with two draft treaties demanding, among other things, a halt to the Alliance’s enlargement and a return to certain military arrangements predating 1997. Today’s demands are entirely consistent with that line. The central question, then, is whether Washington will agree to discuss a new European security architecture seriously with Moscow, and how far the Europeans will be able to shape the terms of any such agreement.
Europe Absent from the Table
That the Europeans were absent from the negotiating table comes as no surprise. Since the start of the war, they have refused any dialogue with Russia, and the bulk of their diplomatic efforts has been devoted to blocking the Russian-American agreement negotiated in Anchorage, Alaska, on 15 August 2025.
The Europeans want to preserve the status quo. “We do not need a new security architecture,” declared German Foreign Minister Johann Wadephul. Kaja Kallas, the EU’s chief diplomat, says the same. On 9 November in Paris, on the eve of the Abu Dhabi talks, she stated: “The problem is that we already have a European security architecture in place that Russia has agreed to.” She cited the Helsinki Final Act and the Budapest Memorandum. Yet the argument does not survive her own statements. Kallas wants Ukraine to be “integrated into this architecture” – that is, into NATO and the European Union. Bringing Ukraine into the Atlantic Alliance, however, would upend the security balance of the continent. In short, Kallas does not reject a new architecture: she merely refuses to discuss it with Russia, while intending to reshape it as she sees fit…
Under these conditions, it is hard to see a way out of the deadlock. We will most likely have to wait for a change in Europe’s political leadership, beginning with the departure of the deeply unpopular Emmanuel Macron (83% unfavourable, according to YouGov, November 2026) and Friedrich Merz (86% dissatisfied, according to Forsa/RTL-ntv, 10 November 2026). By then, the situation on the battlefield will likely have deteriorated for Ukraine, and the Kremlin’s demands will have hardened.